Myanmar and Kashmir: A Historic ICJ Genocide Judgement and the Urgent Warning the International Community Must Not Ignore
The Rohingya Genocide Judgement Must Become a Turning Point for International Accountability – The World Cannot Afford to Wait for Another Humanitarian Catastrophe in Indian-Administered Jammu and Kashmir
By Salman KhanSouth Africa Kashmiri Action Group (SAKAG)
19th November 2026.
Introduction: A Historic Day for International Justice
On 19 November 2026, the International Court of Justice (ICJ), the principal judicial organ of the United Nations, delivered a landmark judgement in the case of The Gambia v. Myanmar, finding Myanmar responsible for genocide against the Rohingya population. This historic decision represents a defining moment in international jurisprudence, human rights protection and the accountability of states for crimes committed against vulnerable populations.
The judgement is more than a legal determination concerning Myanmar. It is a powerful reminder that sovereignty cannot be used as a shield against international accountability, that the systematic persecution of vulnerable communities cannot be ignored indefinitely, and that the international community has an obligation to act when credible evidence points towards grave violations of fundamental human rights.
The Rohingya tragedy did not emerge overnight. It was preceded by decades of discrimination, institutionalised exclusion, restrictions on citizenship, political marginalisation, displacement and successive military operations. The 1982 Citizenship Law effectively rendered most Rohingya stateless, stripping them of fundamental rights and leaving them increasingly vulnerable to persecution.
The military operations of 1978 and 1991–1992, the violence of 2012 and, ultimately, the devastating military clearance operations of 2016–2017 culminated in mass killings, sexual violence, destruction of villages and the displacement of more than 700,000 Rohingya into Bangladesh.
The international community had received repeated warnings. Investigations, testimonies, humanitarian reports and appeals from civil society organisations had documented the deteriorating situation. Yet meaningful international intervention failed to prevent the catastrophe.
The question confronting the world today is whether the lessons of Myanmar will finally be applied elsewhere, before another population experiences an irreversible humanitarian tragedy.
For the South Africa Kashmiri Action Group (SAKAG), this question brings renewed urgency to the unresolved dispute over Jammu and Kashmir.

Acknowledging South African Solidarity, Advocacy and Activism
It would be remiss of us not to acknowledge the selfless, relentless and principled efforts of those individuals and organisations in South Africa who contributed to the advocacy, mobilisation and legal support surrounding the genocide case against Myanmar. Particular recognition must be extended to the South African chapter of the Muslim Lawyers Association (MLA) and the Media Review Network (MRN), whose commitment to international justice and human rights deserves our sincere appreciation. We especially acknowledge the tireless advocacy and activism of Shabnam Mayet, Attorney Ziyaad Patel, Attorney Yousha Tayob, Advocate Feroz Boda, Iqbal Jassat and others who have consistently stood on the side of justice, human dignity and the protection of oppressed communities. These are among the relatively few courageous voices in South Africa who have also demonstrated solidarity with the struggle for justice and the rights of the people of Kashmir. Their work reminds us that the defence of human rights must transcend geographical boundaries, political interests and religious affiliations. Their contribution is not merely an act of solidarity with the Rohingya people; it is an affirmation of the universal principle that injustice anywhere must concern humanity everywhere. It is important to mention that SAKAG led Salman Khan was the part of organizing committee to a mass demonstration and Myanmar embassy in 2017. SAKAG recognises and salutes their commitment, courage and unwavering determination to ensure that the voices of the oppressed are neither silenced nor forgotten.
Kashmir: Almost Eight Decades of Unresolved Dispute and Human Suffering
The question of Jammu and Kashmir has remained unresolved since the partition of British India in 1947. What began as a dispute over the political future and territorial status of a princely state subsequently evolved into one of the longest-standing conflicts on the United Nations Security Council's agenda.
The United Nations Security Council adopted Resolution 47 on 21 April 1948, addressing the restoration of peace and order and the proposed plebiscite in Jammu and Kashmir. Subsequent international deliberations and resolutions reinforced the importance of resolving the dispute peacefully and addressing the aspirations of its people.
However, almost 79 years later, the fundamental political question remains unresolved.
For generations, the people of Jammu and Kashmir have lived with uncertainty, militarisation, political contestation, displacement and recurring cycles of violence.
From the late 1980s onwards, the region experienced an especially severe escalation of armed conflict, accompanied by serious allegations of human rights violations involving state security forces and non-state armed groups.
SAKAG draws attention to estimates indicating that more than 100,000 people have lost their lives in Jammu and Kashmir since 1947, although casualty estimates vary between sources and periods. Behind every number is a family, a community and a human life.
The issue is not merely territorial sovereignty or competing national claims. It is fundamentally about human dignity, political representation, the right to self-determination, civilian protection and the obligation to uphold international humanitarian and human rights standards.
The people of Kashmir cannot be expected to live indefinitely in a state of political limbo while the international community continues to treat their unresolved future as a secondary diplomatic concern.
The UN Human Rights Reports: International Warnings That Must Not Be Ignored
The international community cannot claim that the human rights situation in Kashmir has gone undocumented.
In June 2018, the United Nations Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights published its first comprehensive report on the human rights situation in Indian-Administered Kashmir and Pakistan-Administered Kashmir.
A second report, published in July 2019, examined developments between May 2018 and April 2019. These reports documented serious allegations, including unlawful killings, excessive use of force, arbitrary detention, torture, restrictions on freedom of expression and assembly, and the absence of effective accountability.
The 2018 report highlighted the extensive use of pellet-firing shotguns during the 2016 uprising, documenting civilian casualties and serious injuries, including injuries resulting in permanent blindness. It also highlighted the lack of effective investigations into alleged violations and the obstacles to securing justice for victims.
Importantly, OHCHR recommended that the United Nations Human Rights Council consider establishing an independent international commission of inquiry to investigate allegations of human rights violations in Kashmir. The reports also addressed abuses committed by armed groups, demonstrating the need for impartial investigations into violations by all parties.
Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch have likewise documented serious human rights concerns, including excessive force, arbitrary detention, restrictions on civil liberties and impunity.
These are not allegations that should be dismissed without examination. Nor should they be treated as a substitute for independent judicial findings. They demand credible, impartial and transparent international investigation.
The absence of meaningful accountability risks perpetuating a cycle in which violations continue while victims are denied justice.
Myanmar and Kashmir: The Warning Signs of Prolonged Disenfranchisement
It is important to recognise that Myanmar and Kashmir are distinct political, historical and legal situations. The ICJ's judgement concerning Myanmar does not establish that genocide has occurred in Kashmir, nor does it determine the legal status of Jammu and Kashmir.
Nevertheless, there are important humanitarian and preventive lessons that deserve international attention.
In both situations, prolonged political exclusion, competing national identities, allegations of discrimination, restrictions on fundamental rights and the failure to resolve underlying grievances have contributed to sustained insecurity and human suffering.
The Rohingya experience demonstrates how decades of marginalisation can create conditions in which an already vulnerable population becomes increasingly exposed to systematic abuses.
Kashmir presents a different but equally compelling challenge for preventive diplomacy: an unresolved international dispute, a population whose political aspirations remain contested, recurring violence, extensive security deployment and persistent allegations of human rights violations.
The danger lies in allowing political grievances, communal tensions and perceptions of collective exclusion to deepen without credible mechanisms for dialogue, accountability and peaceful resolution. The international community must not wait for the threshold of genocide to be established before recognising that a humanitarian crisis requires intervention.
Prevention must begin before mass atrocities occur, not after the international community has counted the dead.
The Responsibility of South Africa and the International Community
South Africa occupies a particularly important position in this debate.
Its own history demonstrates the devastating consequences of institutionalised discrimination, racial exclusion, political disenfranchisement and the denial of human dignity.
South Africa's transition from apartheid to constitutional democracy was not achieved through international indifference. It was supported by decades of international solidarity, diplomatic pressure, civil society mobilisation and the collective recognition that injustice could not be normalised.
South Africa therefore has both a moral responsibility and an opportunity to contribute constructively to the peaceful resolution of the Kashmir dispute.
As a country whose foreign policy has consistently emphasised multilateralism, human rights, international law and peaceful conflict resolution, South Africa should use its diplomatic standing to encourage renewed international engagement.
SAKAG respectfully calls upon:
1. The Government of South Africa and DIRCO
To raise the unresolved Jammu and Kashmir question through appropriate diplomatic and multilateral channels, advocate for the protection of civilian populations and support impartial international investigations into credible allegations of human rights violations.
2. The United Nations and the Human Rights Council
To revisit the recommendations contained in the 2018 and 2019 OHCHR reports, including the proposal for an independent international commission of inquiry, and strengthen international human rights monitoring and accountability mechanisms.
3. The United Nations Security Council
To renew meaningful diplomatic engagement with the unresolved Kashmir dispute, taking account of its historical resolutions and the need for a peaceful settlement consistent with international law.
4. International civil society and human rights organisations
To strengthen independent documentation, advocacy, humanitarian engagement and support for victims, survivors and affected communities, without political selectivity.
5. Global powers and influential multilateral partners
To ensure that strategic, economic and geopolitical relationships do not take precedence over fundamental human rights. Consistent international standards must apply irrespective of the political or economic influence of the states concerned.
The Need for Preventive Diplomacy, Not Another Humanitarian Tragedy
The ICJ judgement against Myanmar should serve as a turning point in the way the international community approaches prolonged conflicts and the protection of vulnerable populations.
International justice is important, but justice after mass atrocities cannot restore every life lost, every family destroyed or every community displaced.
The Genocide Convention of 1948 places obligations on states to prevent and punish genocide. The broader international human rights framework also requires states and international institutions to take credible threats to civilian populations seriously.
Preventive diplomacy, early warning mechanisms, independent investigations, accountability and meaningful political dialogue must therefore become central components of international engagement.
In Kashmir, the immediate priority must be the protection of civilians, the prevention of further violence, the restoration of fundamental freedoms, the investigation of alleged violations and the creation of conditions for a peaceful political settlement.
The people of Jammu and Kashmir must not become another generation sacrificed to geopolitical rivalry and diplomatic inertia.
A sustainable resolution must recognise the historical and political dimensions of the dispute, respect the rights and dignity of all communities, and provide a credible framework for addressing the aspirations of the people concerned. Neither military force nor political rhetoric alone can resolve a dispute that has endured for almost eight decades.
Conclusion: The World Must Not Wait for Kashmir's Myanmar Moment
The judgement delivered by the International Court of Justice on 19 November 2026 is a historic affirmation that grave international crimes cannot simply be buried beneath the passage of time or protected by state authority.
The Rohingya people endured decades of exclusion, discrimination and persecution before the international community secured a definitive judicial determination of Myanmar's responsibility for genocide. The lesson for the world is unmistakable: early warnings must be taken seriously, credible allegations must be independently investigated, and preventive action must not be postponed until human suffering becomes irreversible.
For almost 79 years, Jammu and Kashmir has remained an unresolved international dispute. Its people have endured generations of uncertainty, violence, displacement and political disenfranchisement.
SAKAG does not contend that the legal findings in Myanmar automatically apply to Kashmir. Rather, we contend that the international community has sufficient historical and documented human rights concerns to justify urgent, serious and sustained preventive engagement.
The world must not wait for another genocide, another mass displacement or another humanitarian catastrophe before finding the political courage to act.
South Africa, the United Nations, international civil society and the major powers must rise above geopolitical convenience and reaffirm their commitment to human dignity, international law and peaceful conflict resolution.
Kashmir must not become another tragedy that the world acknowledges only after it is too late.
The time for meaningful international engagement is now.
The South Africa Kashmiri Action Group (SAKAG) calls upon the Government of South Africa, the United Nations and the international community to act with urgency, consistency and moral courage in support of a peaceful, just and sustainable resolution of the Jammu and Kashmir dispute.
By Salman Khan. Paul Harris Fellow, T.I
Founder and ChairmanSouth Africa Kashmiri Action Group (SAKAG)
Kashmir Center for African Union (KCAU)
Kashmir Global Movement (KGM)
Executive Member Kashmir Diaspora Coalition (KDC)
Supporting references and source material
For an academic and diplomatic publication, I recommend retaining a short reference list alongside the article. These are particularly important sources:
1. International Court of Justice (19 November 2026): The Gambia v. Myanmar, Application of the Genocide Convention. Judgement and case documentation.
ICJ Web+1
2. United Nations Security Council (1948): Resolution 47 concerning the restoration of peace and order and a plebiscite in Jammu and Kashmir. UN Digital Library.
Digital Library
3. OHCHR (14 June 2018): Report on the Situation of Human Rights in Kashmir: Developments in the Indian State of Jammu and Kashmir from June 2016 to April 2018.
Amazon Web Services, Inc.+1
4. OHCHR (8 July 2019): Update of the Situation of Human Rights in Indian-Administered Kashmir and Pakistan-Administered Kashmir from May 2018 to April 2019.
5. Amnesty International (2016): India: Global Standards on Police Use of Force Violated in Kashmir.
Amnesty International USA
6. Human Rights Watch (2026): World Report 2026: India.
Human Rights Watch




Comments